Whether you are building a new house or replacing your HVAC system, it is important to know what size system you actually need. A central air conditioner is by far the most expensive system in a home. Therefore, you want to ensure the right unit is purchased and installed.
In this article, we will go over the correct way to find the right size central air conditioner using what is called a manual j calculation. Then, we will look at other factors that affect sizing.
What is Manual J Calculation?
Manual J Calculation is a method used to determine proper air conditioner size. It uses the size of the house as well as other detailed factors to determine a home’s heat load. This should be used not only in new construction but when replacing a unit as well.
Why Does Size Matter?
It is important to choose the correct size of air conditioner for your home. Using a unit that is too large will cause it to short cycle, which will shorten its life, and it will also not run long enough to remove humidity.
On the other hand, going with a unit that is too small will have the opposite effect by forcing it to run more than it is designed to. Therefore, it will also not last as long as it should, and the house will not reach a comfortable temperature.
Why Not Use Square Feet to Determine Size?
Some contractors and HVAC technicians will use square footage to determine air conditioner sizing. You may have even had someone tell you 1 ton to 500 square feet. While this will get you in the ballpark, it is not accurate enough to make a final decision.
Who Does Manual J Calculation?
Your HVAC contractor will be able to calculate manual j for your house. If they do not know what manual j is or make excuses as to why it is not necessary, then you should be wary of using them.
Many HVAC contractors are capable but are unwilling to take the time to calculate the correct size. If you are doing new construction, your engineer will also be able to calculate. Also, if you are getting your house Energy Star certified, your representative will be able to help.
Can I Do My Own Manual J Calculation?
Some HVAC companies do charge for manual j calculations, and you may question adding this expense. While most aspects of HVAC systems are not DIY-friendly, this definitely is. You can calculate manual j yourself to ensure that you are getting the right size unit.
How Do I Calculate Manual J?
Before we get started, let us go over BTUs; 1 ton equals 12,000 BTUs. If your manual j calculation comes out to 30,000 BTU, then you will need a 2.5-ton air conditioner.
Simple Method
There is a simple way to calculate what size air conditioner you need. This is good for those wanting to get a general idea of the size they need. To calculate manual j, the first thing we need to do is calculate the home’s cubic footage.
To get this number, find heated square feet by multiplying the length and width of the inside of your house. Then, measure the distance from the floor to the ceiling. Multiply the square footage by the ceiling height.
Next, count the number of windows and also measure their width and height. Also, count the number of exterior doors. Multiply the number of windows by 1,000, then do the same for doors.
Then, determine the number of occupants that will live in the space. Multiply the number of occupants by 100.
Lastly, add up all the solved numbers, and that will get you the number of BTUs your home needs.
| Formula | Example | |
| Cubic Footage | Length X Width X Height | 20 X 50 X 8=8000 |
| Windows and Doors | (Windows X 1000) + (Doors X 1000) | (8 X 1000) + (2 X 1000) =10,000 |
| Occupants | Occupants X 100 | 4 X 100=400 |
| Total | Add up the solutions | 18,400 BTU |
The home in the sample would require a 1.5-ton central air conditioner. Had we used the 500 square feet to 1-ton rule, the system would have been undersized. This shows why it is important to conduct a manual j calculation.
Complex Method
The method previously covered will give you a general overview, but it lacks some important details. Online calculators take what would be a difficult mathematical equation and turn it into something easy for anyone to do. Below are several factors that an advanced calculation will account for:
- Age of the house
- How much insulation is there
- How much sunlight and shade is it exposed to
- What part of the country is it located
- Are there any high-heat devices inside
When Manual J Calculations May Not Work
Although manual j calculations are the best way to size a central air conditioner, there are times when it may not work. For instance, the first formula we looked at does not take into consideration any external factors or the design of the house.
Another limitation is that some calculators assume that the house is built to modern building codes when in reality, a house may be older and built with inferior materials than would be used today.
External and target internal temperatures may also differ from what the calculator assumes. For instance, most calculators presume interior temperature to be 75F, but you may like your home at 72F.
These three degrees can actually make a big difference because the higher the difference, the harder the unit has to work.
One last factor to consider is whether the ductwork is in a conditioned space. Typically, it is not as ducts are run through attics or crawl spaces. That leaves the potential for air to warm up before it reaches the room.
An example of a space where manual j may not apply is in a garage. It has become increasingly popular in climate control garages, and a simple manual j calculation may not provide a realistic answer.
Garages can be complex because they usually lack the level of insulation that the rest of the house has. In addition, a garage will probably not be as well sealed. Most important is the garage door, which, if not insulated, can greatly throw off a manual j calculation.
Although it is important to use a manual j calculation, it is even more important to understand its limiting factors and when it may not work.
What If Your Contractor Disagrees?
It is not uncommon for your HVAC contractor to say something that contradicts the manual j calculations. That is not necessarily a bad thing as long as their justification is sensible.
For instance, they may notice something about your home’s construction that requires a larger unit.
They may also have experience with similar houses in your area, which makes them recommend something different. Consider their experience and reputation to better understand their trustworthiness.
Does Manual J Calculation Work for Window AC Units?
Because manual j is used to calculate loads within a house, it can be used for window units as well. This also applies to portable air conditioners, although these are much less efficient than window units.
The reason why manual j applies to window units is that manual j is simply a measure of heat loads in a home. These loads are measured in BTU, which is the same unit of measurement used to measure window unit capacity.
It is essential to understand window units work differently than central systems because they do not have ductwork where cool air can be lost. They can also be run only in the rooms that are being used. Making window units more efficient in many applications.
What If The Existing Unit Is Bigger/Smaller?
After calculating manual j, you may find that your house needs a different size than it currently has. It is important to consider what size you currently have.
However, you may find your older unit is no longer cooling efficiently. This may be a symptom of an aging system or low freon and not an undersized unit.
It is common for a home to have an undersized unit. The reason this usually occurs is that developers can save a significant amount of money by going with a smaller unit.
For instance, a 2,000-square-foot house that may require a 4 or 5-ton air conditioner may have a 3-ton air conditioner. The new homeowners do not realize that the unit is not the right size, only that it is new.
Consider Improving Efficiency Instead
Instead of going up in size, your money may be better spent on investing in a more efficient system. There is no one-size-fits-all answer to whether or not you should invest in a more efficient unit. However, if your budget allows, it will be a worthwhile long-term investment.
Another potential investment in efficiency is insulation. If your current unit is not keeping up, you may be losing that cold air. Many homeowners rush to upgrade to a larger unit instead of fixing the underlying problem.
Investing in insulation will not only make your home more comfortable, but it will also help lower your electric bill and take the strain off your air conditioner.
Should I Have a Zoned System?
Zoned systems are good for larger houses, especially those with only one air conditioning unit. Dampers are installed in the ductwork and coincide with thermostats throughout the house to control the climate in rooms that people are in through different parts of the day.
Determining whether or not you would benefit from a zoned system really depends on how much value you place on it. Most residential homeowners do not opt for zoned systems because the installation cost is very high.
If you are installing ductwork in a new home, it is probably best to go ahead and have them installed. If you want to have this done later, it will be significantly more expensive because it is not as easily accessible.
If you have a home and are reusing the existing ductwork, there is not really a need to zone the system at this point. In this scenario, you would be able to still add zones later on.
Should I Choose One Large Unit Or Two Small Units?
Multiple units are commonly found in large multi-story houses. They can also be effective in houses with sleeping areas separate from living areas.
This keeps the unit from cooling an entire house when people are only staying in certain parts. An unforeseen benefit is that if one unit fails, part of the house is still climate-controlled.
The downside of having multiple units is the added cost. You will have two outdoor units and two indoor units, all requiring their own maintenance. The costs to purchase will likely surpass the cost of one large unit.
Depending on the size of your house, multiple units may be your only choice. Residential units typically stop between 5 and 6.5 tons, depending on the manufacturer.
Beyond that, single-story houses that are less than 2,500 square feet will almost always benefit from a single unit.
Can I Upgrade To A Bigger Unit?
If you decide that you do need a bigger unit, your next question should be, “Can I get a bigger unit?” The answer to that is a resounding maybe. This could also be why your HVAC contractor is against upsizing your unit.
Going up a half-ton probably will not be a problem, especially if you are getting a more efficient unit that requires less power. However, going up too much will run you into problems with existing ductwork and electrical.
A larger unit will likely require the upgrading of ductwork and electrical going to the unit. These factors can turn an already expensive job into an extremely expensive job.
Of course, if this is new construction, the added costs will not be nearly as high. Either way, the most important thing is to make sure that the unit is not too big or too small.
Conclusion
Finding the right size central air conditioner may not be the first thing that comes to mind when purchasing a new unit. However, there is nothing worse than spending thousands of dollars on an HVAC system only for it now to work optimally.
Performing due diligence before purchasing will ensure a wise purchase decision and provide a unit that will last for years to come.
Leave a Reply